Rethinking John Lennon’s Assassination

Contents

Lennon Home Page

Main Home Page

 

The FBI’s War on Rock Stars

By Salvador Astucia

 

INTRODUCTION

 

Author’s Personal Thoughts

John Lennon was one of the most beloved and influential people who lived in the Twentieth Century. Although his only claim to fame was singing, playing guitar and writing songs, once he achieved superstar status with his rock group, the Beatles, he used his enormous celebrity to promote the cause of peace. He therefore became a threat to those who profit from war. When the world learned of his murder on December 8, 1980, the outpouring of love and grief for the slain Beatle was overwhelming. In life, John Lennon held no position of direct power. He was not an elected official. He was not a president, a king, or religious leader. He led no crusade, formed no political party. He was merely an entertainer who spoke openly about issues he believed were important. Many have compared the world’s reaction to his death to that exhibited when President John F. Kennedy was assassinated.

I personally was so grief-stricken by Lennon’s sudden death that I became physically ill and quickly developed an ear infection which required antibiotics. I recall stopping at a pharmacy to get my prescription filled, clearly grief-stricken and sick, but I stood in line waiting to pay the cashier for the prescription drugs I needed. Beside me in another line, I heard a young man—a few years older than me—whistling I’ve Just Scene a Face by the Beatles. I knew I was not alone in my pain. For years, I had difficulty reading about his murder. It was so painful to think of someone I felt was my brother being cut down so violently, so brutally. But time has a way of healing wounds. As I grew older I watched some of my loved ones pass on, which gave me strength to reflect on John Lennon’s murder and other tragic events which occurred in my life, but beyond my personal circle of friends and family.

In the final chapter of my book, Opium Lords, (April 2002) I suggested that Lennon was the victim of a government sponsored assassination. Admittedly I focused mainly on motive rather than details of the case because I had not devoted much time to researching the rock star’s murder when I wrote Opium Lords. Nevertheless, I was intrigued that Lennon’s younger son, Sean, had publicly stated his belief that his father was likely assassinated by the United States government. In recent years, Sean reportedly made the following statement:

[He] was a counterrevolutionary and was very dangerous to the government. If he had said ‘Bomb the White House tomorrow,’ there would have been 10,000 people who would have done it. The pacifist revolutionaries are historically killed by the government, and anybody who thinks Mark Chapman was just some crazy guy who killed my dad for his own personal interest is insane or very naive. It was in the best interest of the United States to have my dad killed. And you know, that worked against them, because once he died, his power grew. So I mean, fuck them! They didn’t get what they wanted.1

A short while ago I decided to research John Lennon’s murder in depth. As I suspected Sean was absolutely correct. There was a conspiracy. The United States government had reason to silence John Lennon. I will discuss motive shortly, but for now, let us focus on the crime scene itself. Regardless of motive or the accused killer’s state of mind, I will demonstrate that Mark David Chapman is completely innocent and should therefore be released from prison as soon as possible. Here is a brief summary of my findings:

  • Lennon’s wounds were on the wrong side of his body. The autopsy revealed four wounds to the left side of the upper body: two in the left shoulder, two in the left side of the back. On Dec. 10, 1980, (two days after the murder) the New York Times published a diagram showing where Lennon and Chapman were standing when the fatal shots were fired. Chapman was reportedly standing to Lennon’s right, several feet behind him. Before shooting, Chapman allegedly called to the victim, "Mr. Lennon." As Lennon turned, Chapman fired five shots; four hit Lennon. Since Chapman was reportedly standing to Lennon’s right in back of him, Lennon would certainly have turned to his right in response to Chapman’s call. This means the right side of Lennon’s body was facing Chapman as he turned. The wounds should have been on the right side of the body, but surprisingly they were on the left.

  • The doorman at the Dakota on the night of the shooting was an anti-Castro Cuban, Jose Perdomo; Chapman’s primary accuser. It is widely known that Cuban exiles have been used extensively by the intelligence community since the failed Bay of Pigs invasion in 1961.

  • Patrolman Peter Cullen, one of the officers in the first police car responding to the shooting, believed the shooter was a handyman at the Dakota, not Chapman. Cullen thought Chapman "looked like a guy who worked in a bank." Perdomo convinced Cullen that Chapman was the assailant.

  • Hours after the shooting, the New York Times reported that Lennon was shot near the main lobby in the Dakota entryway. The next day the NYT reported that he was shot near the entrance of the Dakota, about 20-to-25 feet away from the spot originally reported. The shift in location was apparently needed because police and witnesses found Chapman at the entrance of the Dakota building, not 20-to-25 feet inside.

  • Lennon’s true assassin was probably the handyman (aka, elevator operator) who fired from inside or near a service elevator located across from the concierge stand where Lennon collapsed after being shot. Shooting from the service elevator would easily hit the left side of Lennon’s body which is where the wounds were located.

  • Mark David Chapman has never been judged legally insane, although opinion leaders within the American news media continually portray him as crazy. He pled guilty to the crime, thereby forfeiting his right to a trial. As a result, he has spent the last 22 years of his life in Attica State penitentiary for a crime he did not commit.

  • Facts indicate that Chapman was likely the victim of mind control—a combination of drugs, hypnosis or both—which caused him to commit numerous self-incriminating acts; however, murder was not one of them. Ironically, Chapman himself believes he shot Lennon, although he cannot recall several key details of the crime. The power of suggestion is an incredible tool.

  • There are no known witnesses to the crime; however, several "crime scene witnesses" observed events shortly before and after the shooting. But I have found no statements from any person who actually observed Chapman shoot Lennon; not even Yoko Ono.

Fear of Assassination

One of the reasons the Beatles stopped touring in 1966 was because they feared John would be assassinated. On July 29, 1966, Datebook published John’s interview with British journalist Maureen Cleave. Datebook had quoted John out of context, where he stated that the Beatles were "more popular than Jesus." The American magazine’s misrepresentation of the innocent statement created anti-Beatle reactions around America, particularly in the South. On August 12, 1966, just before the Beatles next tour began, John held a press conference in Chicago to explain his comments about Christianity and apologize. On August 19, 1966, the Beatles performed at a Memphis concert and someone let off a firecracker. The entire Beatles’ entourage reportedly looked at John, thinking he had been shot.2 Tony Barrow was public relations manager for the Beatles at that time and witnessed the incident. The following is an excerpt from an interview Barrow gave years later where he discussed John’s remarks about Christianity, the Beatles last tour, and the exploding firecracker in Memphis:

BARROW: The third and final phase of that horrendous year [1966] was the last tour of the United States, where we began with Beatle records being burned and John Lennon under the direct threat of assassination from religious zealots in the southern United States, the Bible Belt states. It was the misconstruing of his comment about Jesus Christ’s diminishing popularity, which wasn’t in any way boastful. It was just a comment he made. By the time it reached certain southern states, it was taken very badly by certain religious factions and there was the threat of death hanging over that whole tour.

I do recall that once we did get down to that area, the southern states, that a firecracker was let off during the concert in Memphis and everybody, all of us at the side of the stage, including the three Beatles on stage, all looked immediately at John Lennon. We would not at that moment have been surprised to see that guy go down. Of course, that was 14 years too early for that. John had halfheartedly joked about the Memphis concert in an earlier press conference, and when we got there everything seemed to be controlled and calm, but underneath somehow, there was this nasty atmosphere. It wasn’t a happy day at all. It was a very tense and pressured kind of day.3

That incident apparently affected John deeply for the rest of his life. Two years later he wrote a rather bizarre song entitled "Happiness is a Warm Gun," which appeared on the Beatles White Album. But once you understand about the firecracker incident in Memphis in 1966, the song seems rather down to earth.

 

     

John Lennon - background

John Winston Lennon was born October 9, 1940 in Oxford Street Maternity Hospital, in the port city of Liverpool, England, during a lull in the WWII bombing of the city. John was the only child of Julia Stanley (b. March 12, 1914 – d. July 15, 1958) and Alfred Lennon (b. December 14, 1912 – d. April 1, 1976) who were married in Liverpool on December 3, 1938. John had two sons: Julian Lennon (b. April 8, 1963) and Sean Lennon (b. October 9, 1975), the elder son from the union with first wife, Cynthia Powell; the younger son from the union with second wife, Yoko Ono. John had five half-siblings (three maternal half-sisters and two paternal half-brothers).

John & Yoko
 
 
 

His half-sisters were Julia Dykins Baird (b. 1947), Jackie Dykins (b. 1949), and Victoria Elizabeth Williams* (b. June 19, 19454)—Julia and Jackie being the offspring of mother Julia and common law husband, John "Bobby" Dykins (b. 1918 - d. 1966); Victoria being the offspring of mother Julia and Taffy Williams. John’s half-brothers were David Henry Lennon (b. February 1969) and Robin Francis Lennon (b. October 1973) from the union of his father and second wife Pauline Jones. John never met his two half-brothers (his father’s sons) who were easily young enough to be John’s sons. John apparently never knew Victoria either; she was reportedly adopted by a Norwegian Captain and his family.

John’s father—Alfred "Freddy" Lennon—was in the Merchant Navy when John was born and consequently was at sea for long stretches of time. World War II pushed the young couple apart and eventually they divorced. John was raised by his mother Julia’s sister, Mary Elizabeth "Mimi" Stanley (b. 1903 - d. December 6, 1992), and her husband George Toogood Smith (b. 1903 - d. June 5, 1955). John grew up at the Smith’s upper middle-class home, a semi-detached house, known as "Mendips" at 251 Menlove Avenue, Woolton. The Smiths had no children of their own.

John lost contact with his father but remained close to his mother, who visited him often at Menlove Avenue. John frequently visited Julia and her common law husband, John "Bobby" Dykins, and their two daughters, Julia and Jackie, at the family’s Liverpool flat. John experienced two traumatic events before he reached adulthood. When he was fourteen, John’s Uncle George died suddenly of a brain hemorrhage. George was 52. Three years later, when John was 17, Julia was killed in a traffic accident when an off duty policeman ran her down as she walked home from Mimi's house. Julia was 44. John never fully recovered emotionally from the shock of losing his mother so tragically, but he transferred his pain into music and inspirational poetic lyrics which would capture the imagination of the world a few years later. That’s really the essence of all art: channeling the artist’s emotions into a creative outlet. And John’s singing voice—when in top form—seemed to radiate from records directly to the listeners’ hearts. He didn’t have strong technical technique; mainly raw, uninhibited emotion. And the sound of his voice was totally unique.

Years later, John’s half-sister Julia Dykins Baird described her mother’s musical and creative influence over John:

JULIA BAIRD: Where did John get his musical talents? Oh, from my mother definitely. Some people, like my cousin, Leila, said that my mother had far more talent than John ever had because he only inherited a slight spot of it. The whole family is biased toward my mother, of course, beautifully so. But she did really have enormous talent. She was a very creative person. She did paintings on the wall, directly on the wall. We grew up with all that around the kitchen chimney. And she would always play. If she was reading us something like "The Teddy Bear’s Picnic" [a children’s story], we’d get the da, da, da, da and the mouth organ and stuff like that. We got it all. Everything was well decorated.

Of course, John was six and a half years older than me, so she was beginning to teach him. She’d been taught the banjo by her grandfather. She’d inherited this beautiful mother-of-pearl, four-string banjo, a very big one. She used to play "That’ll Be the Day" by Buddy Holly, one of the ones John sang later. I remember us standing over him, making him play it again and saying, "Yes, it will hurt. Press harder. Press harder. Yes, it hurts."…5

John eventually migrated from the banjo to the guitar and became friends with two other guitar players, Paul McCartney (b. June 18, 1942), George Harrison (b. February 25, 1943 - d. November 29, 2001). By 1955, the three teenagers were enamored with the new American musical craze, rock ‘n’ roll, and imitated the genre’s leader, Elvis Presley. Eventually the threesome picked up drummer Richard Starkey (aka, Ringo Starr; b. July 7, 1940) and evolved into the Beatles, the most influential rock group of the Twentieth Century. In 1964, "I Want to Hold Your Hand," "Love Me Do," and "She Loves You" stayed at the top of the American charts for months, simultaneous with Capitol Records’ sudden release of nearly 60 Beatles recordings—packaged in five albums—to the American public.* Consequently, their music dominated the airwaves for nearly two years and ushered in Beatlemania, the mass hysteria among their teenage fans across the globe. The songwriting team of John Lennon and Paul McCartney epitomized rock creativity in the Sixties. John added to the Beatles’ mystique with the publication of two humorous books, "A Spaniard in the Works" and "In His Own Write."

On August 23, 1962, John married artist Cynthia Powell (b. September 10, 1939). On April 8, 1963, the couple had a son, Julian Lennon. In July 1964, the young family moved to the "Kenwood" mansion in Weybridge, England. But fame, fortune and constant touring took its toll on the marriage. John and Cynthia divorced on November 8, 1968. On March 20, 1969, John married avant garde Japanese artist Yoko Ono (b. February 18, 1933). The couple quickly became outspoken critics of America’s military involvement in Vietnam. John began recording with Yoko, apart from the Beatles, in the Plastic Ono Band. They recorded memorable anti-war songs such as "Give Peace a Chance," "Instant Karma," "Happy Christmas (War is Over)," and "Imagine."

John also began to express political opinions regarding Britain’s persecution of the Irish. His empathy for the Irish probably came from his hometown, Liverpool, a city closely linked to Ireland culturally and geographically. The famous North-England port city is about 120 miles east of Dublin, separated by the Irish Sea. A high level of Irish immigration to Liverpool occurred during and after the Irish potato famine of 1845 through 1848. Consequently, many of the Irish customs became part of Liverpool’s culture, most notably the prominence of the Roman Catholic Church in a Protestant nation historically opposed to Catholicism and known for its oppression of Irish Catholics.6 Like many Liverpudlians, John was raised Roman Catholic, and consequently, was viewed as a second class citizen within the British social order. In fact, John’s heritage was apparently Irish-Catholic on both the maternal and paternal sides of his family. According to Edward MacLysaght’s book, The Surnames of Ireland, "Lennon" is an Irish surname from Counties Cork, Fermanagh, and Galway.7 "Stanley" (the surname of John’s mother) is a common English name which—according to MacLysaght—"is on record in Ireland since the Thirteenth Century, mainly in the Counties Louth and Meath" and "is now fairly numerous in both Leinster and parts of Munster."8

John’s Irish heritage would certainly explain his innate rebellious nature and his eventual public positions on several Irish political struggles. Contrary to popular belief, John’s opinions about Ireland were probably sincere convictions he held his entire life, being the apparent descendant of Irish immigrants who migrated to Liverpool. Ireland was under British colonial rule for centuries, but became a sovereign, independent, democratic state in 1937, although Northern Ireland remains under British rule to this day. In 1972, John wrote and recorded a song, "Sunday Bloody Sunday,"* which describes how British soldiers shot and killed thirteen Irish civilian demonstrators in the Northern Ireland city of Derry on January 30, 1972.9 Sunday Bloody Sunday appeared on John’s 1972 album, Some Time In New York City. On the same album was "The Luck of the Irish," co-written by John and Yoko, which discusses how the British have persecuted the Irish for a thousand years. Although these songs are considered highly political by many, they are quite similar to other Irish popular songs about British atrocities in Ireland, most notably Pete St. John’s "The Fields of Athenry" which has become a de facto national anthem of Ireland.

John took similar positions, not directly in support of the Irish, but in general opposition to British rule. In 1969, John became active in clearing the name of James Francis Hanratty, a British citizen tried by the British government and subsequently executed (hanged) on April 4, 1962 for the murder of Michael Gregsten (36) and the rape and attempted murder of Valerie Storie (22) on August 22, 1961. Irregularities in the Hanratty case paved the way to ending capital punishment in Britain. On December 11, 1969, John and Yoko startled a crowd of fans outside the Kensington Odeon in London at the premiére of Ringo Starr’s movie, The Magic Christian, by carrying a banner reading "Britain Murdered Hanratty." Three days later, on December 14, 1969, John and Yoko attended a speech made by Hanratty’s father at Speaker’s Corner, Hyde Park, during which the elder Hanratty declared his son’s innocence.10

John was encouraged to express himself politically by his second wife, Yoko Ono. Yoko is the oldest of three children from the marriage of Eisuke Ono and Isoko Yasuda Ono. Prior to World War II, the Ono family was part of Japanese aristocracy,* but they lost everything after Japan’s defeat in World War II. Yoko said later that during the war years she was always hungry, and the family was often reduced to begging for food door to door. Eventually the Ono family acquired new wealth and social prominence in post-war Japan.

Eight years older than John, Yoko had been married twice before. Her first husband was Julliard student, Toshi Ichiyangi. Her second husband was Tony Cox. She and Cox had a daughter, Kyoko Cox (b. August 8, 1963). Many Beatle fans disliked Yoko; many accused her of breaking up the Beatles. In 1998, Yoko reflected on her life with John:

YOKO ONO: They say that Venus was jealous of lovers. Forget Venus. In our case it was the whole world. But as far as we were concerned, we felt lucky that we had found each other. Aside of the fact that we were both rebellious and emotional, we were true opposites. John was tallish. I was smallish. John made music for the people. I made music for the avant-garde…John was humble, in a way only a very successful person could be. I was proud, like most people living in an Ivory Tower, who never had to test the big water. Coming from a semi-working class background, John was street-wise. I was totally inexperienced when it came to the games of the real world. And we felt so, so lucky that we fell in love with each other. It was a blessing neither of us expected at that time in our lives. We couldn’t take our eyes off one another. We couldn’t get enough of each other. But the outside pressure was very strong. It was so strong, that sometimes we had to separate from each other in order to protect our love. We thought we were clever, that we did everything right, and nothing and nobody could tear us apart. Never, never, never. But it happened: our separation. So sudden, too. He was taken away from me for good.11

In 1971, John and Yoko moved to New York City to find Kyoko, who was being kept away from Yoko by Cox. In June 1973, John and Yoko moved to the Dakota, a chic condominium complex in Manhattan. Shortly after moving in, John and Yoko separated for 15 months, but eventually reconciled. On October 9, 197512 (John’s 35th birthday), Yoko gave birth to a son, Sean. John spent the ensuing five years in seclusion but returned to public life in the fall of 1980. He was assassinated on December 8, 1980. A memorial to John—"Strawberry Fields"—stands in New York City's Central Park West.13

The day after John was killed, Yoko publicly asked people to send donations, in lieu of flowers, to the Spirit Foundation, then located at 1 Battery Park Plaza, New York, NY 10004. She described the Spirit Foundation as "John’s personal charitable foundation." Yoko said the foundation was set up a year earlier by John with a grant of $100,000. The Foundation’s assets were devoted to the following causes: Hale House, East Harlem Family Health Service, Covenant House, Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children, New York Foundling Hospital, St. Barnabas House Salvation Army, the WBAI-Pacifica radio network, the Police Athletic League and the New York City Police Department Vest Fund to purchase bulletproof vests for officers and WNET, the public television channel.14

 

Strawberry Fields plaque in Central Park West
Imagine Memorial in Strawberry Fields, Central Park West

Go to Chapter 1

Go to Preface

Contents

Lennon Home Page

Main Home Page

ORDER BOOK

 

http://www.jfkmontreal.com/order_hardcopy.htm

ENDNOTES
 
1 Geoffrey Giuliano, Lennon in America, p. 222
2 Two sources describe the firecracker incident in Memphis: (1) David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght, The Beatles: An Oral History, p 224; (2) Marie Clayton & Gareth Thomas, John Lennon: Unseen Archives, p 167. The date of the Memphis concert (August 19, 1966) is shown on a 1966 tour schedule on a Beatles webpage: http://www.beatles.ws/1966.htm.
3 David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght, The Beatles: An Oral History, p 224
4 Ray Coleman, Lennon: The Definitive Biography, p 88
5 David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght, The Beatles: An Oral History, pp. 5-6
6 SOURCES: (1) Encyclopedia Britannica: Liverpool; (2) American Automobile Association (AAA): Map of England, Wales & Republic of Ireland
7 Edward MacLysaght, The Surnames of Ireland, p 194
8 ibid, p 278
9 Remembering Bloody Sunday, http://larkspirit.com/bloodysunday/
10 SOURCES: (1) Ray Coleman, Lennon: The Definitive Biography, p 710; (2) Marie Clayton & Gareth Thomas, John Lennon: Unseen Archives, pp. 283, 285 & 287
11 Yoko Ono, Lennon Anthology: Introduction, pp. 2-5
12 Ray Coleman, Lennon: The Definitive Biography, pp 590 & 595. (Page 590 states that John and Yoko’s separation began in the autumn of 1973. Page 595 states that the separation lasted for 15 months.)
13 SOURCES (Lennon bio): (1) Ray Coleman, Lennon: The Definitive Biography; (2) Hunter Davis, The Beatles, Second Revised Edition; (3) David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght, The Beatles: An Oral History; (4) http://www.lennon.net; (5) http://www.instantkarma.com/yokobio.html
14 SOURCES: (1) Announcement, New York Times, Dec. 10, 1980, "Yoko Ono Asks Mourners to Give To a Foundation Lennon Favored;" (2) Paul L. Montgomery, New York Times, Dec. 11, 1980, "Suspect in Lenon’s Slaying is Put Under Suicide Watch," p B3