Salvador Slamdunks Critic on Moderated Newsgroup

From: Salvadorwriter (salvadorwriter@cs.com)
Subject: Re: British Historian David Irving notices Salvador Astucia
Newsgroups: alt.assassination.jfk

Date: 2002-06-07 23:18:45 PST
 

>>Friends,
>>
>>I am pleased to announce that I will be giving a lecture on the JFK
>>assassination at David Irving's Real History Conference on Labor Day
>>weekend in Cincinnati, Ohio.
>>
>>The four-day weekend will include several guest speakers, a cruise, and
>>two gala dinners all for $410.
>>
>>To learn more about the Real History Conference, click here:
>>http://www.jfkmontreal.com
>>
>>Best regards,
>>
>>Salvador Astucia
>>Author of "Opium Lords: Israel, the Golden Triangle, and the Kennedy
>>Assassination"
>>
>Before anyone starts clearing the calendar, I would suggest Michael
>Shermerer's
>DENYING HISTORY.  The same subject of Holocaust denial is also dealt with in
>his WHY PEOPLE BELIEVE WEIRD THINGS.
>
>Irving is not an historian proper, but a writer and researcher.  As a prof
>said
>over 20 years ago:  yes, some of the material produced by Irving _is_
>interesting, but be _VERY_ careful as to how that material is interpreted. 
>Over the intervening decades, Irving has slipped the traces from tendentious
>to
>flake, sad really.
>
>Bill B

Apparently you believe that Lee Harvey Oswald alone killed JFK. I have
concluded that because you have labeled David Irving a "flake" merely
because he questions some of the facts about the official Holocaust story
just as many question the conclusion of the Warren Commission. I have
noticed that almost everyone who supports the Warren Report also endorses
the official Holocaust story. Hence, I must conclude that you endorse the
Warren Report. Am I correct?

A prime example of such twisted thinking is Gerald Posner. In addition to
writing "Case Closed," he also authored the following books:

* "Hitler?s Children: Sons and Daughters of Leaders of the Third Reich
Talk About Their Fathers and Themselves" (1991)
 
* "Mengele: The Complete Story" (2000)

Another interesting point is that most public figures, like Posner, who
poo-poo any notion of governmental conspiracy are usually Jewish. Yet
these non-conspiratorial Jewish sources keep pushing the biggest
conspiracy theory of all time--that Hitler had a MasterPlan to exterminate
Jews. The truth is, Jews were so disliked in Germany during the 1930s that
the only sort of Masterplan required was a way to keep them alive. Now
that would have required one hell of a conspiracy.

Salvador
http://www.jfkmontreal.com